Problem
The preregistered vrs-catalog-activation-present / vrs-catalog-activation-absent provider pair is held because the current provider launch path cannot guarantee both of these properties:
- a hard USD 0.05 cap enforced before and during each cell; and
- exactly one normalized usage/cost receipt available after every provider termination, including product failure and watchdog timeout.
Source-level command assertions are insufficient. If a provider process is externally terminated before its usage data is durably emitted, the runner cannot safely distinguish a product timeout from an infrastructure/accounting failure.
This is the external capability blocking the paid half of draft PR #60. The PR's model-free A–D proof and living-spec judge remain frozen; no paid result is inferred.
Required adapter contract
Before launch, the selected provider path must prove a real hard ceiling of USD 0.05 for the complete cell.
After termination, it must emit exactly one normalized receipt bound to:
- schema version;
- exact cell;
- provider and model;
- non-negative integer input/output token counts;
- actual
cost_usd;
- exact
budget_usd: 0.05; and
- termination status:
pass, fail, timeout, or error.
The runner must durably persist the receipt before verdict classification.
Acceptance
The existing public model-free boundary harness in PR #60 must remain green:
- product FAIL plus valid under-budget receipt persists, then paired control runs;
- watchdog timeout plus valid under-budget timeout receipt persists, then paired control runs;
- missing or malformed receipt writes
STOPPED before control; and
- valid over-budget receipt persists, then writes
STOPPED before control.
A real adapter acceptance must additionally prove that its cap is enforced by the provider path and that timeout teardown cannot race or erase the receipt. Provider-specific work belongs to the owning adapter/runtime repository; this evals issue owns the cross-repo acceptance dependency and unblock criteria.
Guardrails
- Do not weaken the VRS living-spec judge.
- Do not alter the frozen matched inputs to manufacture a result.
- Do not infer authorization for a provider run from this issue.
- Keep the pair held until an exact owner-reviewed adapter source and immutable capability receipt are linked here.
Problem
The preregistered
vrs-catalog-activation-present/vrs-catalog-activation-absentprovider pair is held because the current provider launch path cannot guarantee both of these properties:Source-level command assertions are insufficient. If a provider process is externally terminated before its usage data is durably emitted, the runner cannot safely distinguish a product timeout from an infrastructure/accounting failure.
This is the external capability blocking the paid half of draft PR #60. The PR's model-free A–D proof and living-spec judge remain frozen; no paid result is inferred.
Required adapter contract
Before launch, the selected provider path must prove a real hard ceiling of USD 0.05 for the complete cell.
After termination, it must emit exactly one normalized receipt bound to:
cost_usd;budget_usd: 0.05; andpass,fail,timeout, orerror.The runner must durably persist the receipt before verdict classification.
Acceptance
The existing public model-free boundary harness in PR #60 must remain green:
STOPPEDbefore control; andSTOPPEDbefore control.A real adapter acceptance must additionally prove that its cap is enforced by the provider path and that timeout teardown cannot race or erase the receipt. Provider-specific work belongs to the owning adapter/runtime repository; this evals issue owns the cross-repo acceptance dependency and unblock criteria.
Guardrails