Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
45 lines (43 loc) · 14 KB

ASSUMPTIONS.md

File metadata and controls

45 lines (43 loc) · 14 KB

Assumption ledger

One row per modelling assumption: what it affects, how it was tested, and what the test showed. "Not tested" is a valid entry and means the risk is open.

ID Assumption Affects Test Result
A1 Balanced three-phase conditions; dq model with no zero sequence Everything. Unbalanced faults cannot be studied Step 07 wrote the current-loop model in phase coordinates and ran a balanced event The D-Q equations hold for balanced conditions: growth rates within 0.00014 1/s, zero sequence below 2e-9 pu. Unbalanced conditions still not studied
A2 Stator and network flux transients are kept Existence of the sub-synchronous mode test_series_rlc_modes_appear_at_f0_minus_and_plus_fer: the network block gives modes at f0 ± f_er with decay R wb / 2X. Step 06 removed the transients from the linearised System B2 Holds to 0.02 Hz and 0.2 %. Without them the sub-synchronous mode does not exist: 28 unstable cases of 54 all reported stable, growth up to 28 1/s missed. Required
A3 Line is a lumped series R-L-C; no shunt capacitance, no frequency dependence of R Resonant frequency and network damping Not tested. A distributed-line comparison belongs in Phase 2 Open
A4 Machine circuit parameters from the classical conversion of standard parameters Rotor resistances, and through them the negative resistance and all damping Reactances checked at the limits X(0) and X(∞). Time constants not compared with the exact conversion Reactances exact. Time-constant error not quantified
A5 Slip calculation averages the d and q operational reactances Hand estimate of resonance and growth rate Compared with the locked-shaft eigenvalue of the full electrical model over X_C = 0.02 to 0.62 pu Growth rate within 2.6 %, frequency within 0.09 Hz
A6 Damping-torque estimate is first-order in the coupling between electrical and torsional modes Torsional growth-rate estimate Compared with full eigenvalues over the same sweep Within 0.04 1/s where growth is below 0.2 1/s. Overestimates the mode 1 peak by 86 % (7.34 against 3.95 1/s). Peak location agrees
A7 No mechanical damping (D_i = 0) Torsional growth rates are worst-case; small positive values appear at every compensation level By construction. Real units have small positive modal damping Stated, not tested. Stability margins from this model are pessimistic
A8 Constant field voltage and constant mechanical torque (no AVR, no governor) Low-frequency swing mode; negligible above 10 Hz Not tested Open; expected small for torsional frequencies
A9 No magnetic saturation Operating-point reactances Not tested Open
A10 Fixed-step RK4 at 0.1 to 0.2 ms Time-domain accuracy Convergence study against DOP853 at tight tolerance; observed order 4.00 Error 1.5e-8 at 0.125 ms over 0.5 s. System B2 growth rate (step 06): error 3e-6 1/s at 0.5 ms, 8e-5 at 1 ms, 0.014 at 3 ms; unstable above 4.0 ms
A11 Benchmark data entered from memory of secondary sources Every number for System A Shaft data reproduce the five published torsional frequencies to 0.005 Hz, which pins inertias and stiffnesses jointly. Network and generator data have no such check Shaft: confirmed indirectly. Network resistance split and generator data: to be checked against the 1977 paper
A12 Induction machine data entered from memory of secondary sources (2 MW class, single cage) Every number for System B1, most of all the boundary through R_r Boundary mapped against R_r from 0.004 to 0.030 pu, so the sensitivity is known: 97 % compensation at 0.0055 pu, 73 % at 0.010 pu, 44 % at 0.020 pu Sensitivity quantified. Source values to be checked
A13 Single-cage rotor with constant R_r Rotor resistance at slip frequency. Double-cage and deep-bar rotors have higher resistance at high slip frequency, which would lower the boundary Not tested Open. Direction of the error known: the model is optimistic for such rotors
A14 No shunt capacitors at the plant terminals, no collector system Operating range and reactive balance. Below about 25 % compensation the line cannot carry 0.9 pu Observed as a pull-out limit in the steady-state solver Sweeps start at 30 % for System B1. Step 05 added a plant-side series impedance of 0.010 + j0.15 pu to System B2: the boundary at a 10 Hz loop and rated speed moves from 21 % to 42 % compensation. Shunt capacitors still not modelled
A15 Single lumped mass, constant mechanical torque Coupling between rotor motion and the network mode Compared with the speed held: growth rate moves by at most 0.24 1/s, boundary by at most 0.9 points of compensation Small. A two-mass drive train is not modelled
A16 The plant is one aggregated machine Everything for Systems B1 and B2 Step 05 varied the fraction of identical units online from 5 % to 100 % Not monotonic: worst at 35 to 65 % online, where growth is up to 2.6 1/s above the full plant and the boundary is up to 13 points lower. Unequal units and unequal wind not tested
A17 Slip calculation evaluates the machine at the real frequency jω Energy accounting and R_machine for oscillations that are not steady Compared with the waveform: 1.4 % for a sustained oscillation, 13 % at −2.4 1/s, 9.5 % at +6.9 1/s. At the complex frequency: at most 2.1 %. With speed held as well: 2e-9 Holds near the boundary. Away from it, use the complex frequency
A18 Ideal synchronous frame for the rotor current controller: no phase-locked loop, no measurement or switching delay Controller behaviour near the sub-synchronous frequency; any phase lag changes how much of the gain acts as resistance Step 04 added the loop and swept it from 1 to 60 Hz at 50 % compensation Shifts the growth rate by −5.4 1/s at 0.75 pu speed and +1.4 1/s at 1.20 pu at the default 10 Hz. Delays are still not modelled
A19 Constant rotor current references: no outer power or voltage loops; rotor speed is a parameter Low-frequency behaviour and the dependence on operating point. With these choices the model is linear and its eigenvalues do not depend on dispatch Step 04 freed the rotor and added outer loops At most +0.5 1/s at the default 1 Hz outer loop. Not negligible when the outer loop is fast: +13 1/s at 20 Hz and 0.75 pu speed
A20 Quick growth-rate estimate (net resistance over reactance slope) is first order in net resistance The σ_hand feature Compared with the solver against gain: 9.1 against 8.3 1/s at Kp = 0.01, 57.6 against 35.6 1/s at Kp = 0.10 Holds for growth below about 10 1/s. The circuit root has no such limit
A21 Controller gain treated as plain rotor resistance (Ki dropped) in the hand calculation Hand boundary for System B2 Largest stable gain compared with the solver over 18 compensation levels and 3 speeds 1.9 % at the tuned Ki / Kp of 10.9 1/s, 19 % at ten times that, 400 % at a hundred times. Always optimistic
A22 No grid-side converter, no DC link, plant connected radially with nothing else on the bus Absolute stability limits of System B2 Step 04 added the grid-side converter and DC link. With voltage feed-forward they move the growth rate at rated speed by 0.6 1/s The gap to practice is not explained by them. Step 05 tested the network: plant impedance plus one parallel path as strong as the line raises the largest stable current-loop bandwidth at rated speed from 3.5 to 19.2 Hz. Limits remain relative only
A23 Grid-side converter feeds the terminal voltage forward through a 2 ms filter How much the grid-side converter damps the sub-synchronous mode Compared with no feed-forward, and swept the filter from 0.5 to 50 ms Largest effect after the current-loop gain. No feed-forward: −7 1/s and up to 32 points of compensation at the boundary. Slowing the filter to 50 ms: −5 to −7 1/s. Actual plant practice not confirmed
A24 Converters are ideal voltage sources: no switching, no modulation limit, DC voltage does not scale the output Coupling between the DC link and the oscillation Not tested Open
A25 Power follows rotor speed cubed and mechanical power is constant Operating point at each rotor speed (0.244 pu at 0.75, 1 pu at 1.20) and slow speed dynamics Not tested against a turbine model Open; affects low-frequency modes more than the sub-synchronous one
A26 No current, voltage or rate limits Large-signal behaviour. An unstable case grows without bound Compensation step of 5 points: growth rate from the waveform within 0.005 1/s of the eigenvalue while the swing is below 0.6 pu Valid for small oscillations only. Sustained oscillation amplitude cannot be predicted
A27 Plant-side impedance of 0.010 + j0.15 pu and parallel paths with the line's X/R are representative values Size of the network effects in step 05 Swept: network resistance 0.5 to 8 times, parallel path 0.25 to 32 times the line impedance Sensitivity known. Values not tied to a real plant
A28 Network variations are studied with the current-loop model in impedance form Parallel path and units-online results Radial case agrees with the state-space model to 2.3e-8. Full controls agree with the current-loop model within 4 points of compensation on the radial case (step 04) Plant impedance and parallel path since confirmed in the time-domain model: 0.0005 1/s with the added loops off, within 2.3 1/s with full controls. Units online not confirmed in the time domain
A29 Dropping network transients is tested on the linearised model, not with a nonlinear positive-sequence model The comparison in step 06 Not tested further Sufficient for whether the mode exists. Says nothing about large-signal positive-sequence behaviour
A30 The generic converter (System C) is an averaged model: no switching, no control delay, no current or voltage limits, and a single filter reactor with no filter capacitor Behaviour above a few hundred hertz; large-signal behaviour Step 28 adds a delay and a filter capacitor: an instability at the filter resonance in a quarter to a third of cases, and the verdict below 58 Hz changed in 1.6 % of cases with a phase-locked loop Delay and capacitor lifted in step 28 as a separate study; datasets and steps 17 to 27 are without them. Limits still out
A37 The control delay is a second-order Padé approximant per axis, with the frame rotation compensated; the network above 58 Hz is still series R and X with no shunt capacitance The high-frequency results of step 28 Step 30 adds shunt capacitance: a delay alone then makes 44.5 % and 49.1 % of cases unstable. Not tested against an exact delay The inductive network is not safe above 58 Hz. Numbers for the longest delays are open
A38 Shunt capacitance of the network is one lossless capacitor on the plant bus, 0.01 to 0.30 pu, drawn evenly on a logarithmic scale The shares of unstable cases above 58 Hz in step 30 Not tested against a distributed line or a cable with losses. The range is a choice, not data Shows the mechanism and that an inductive network model misses it. The shares are for this choice
A39 Protection of the doubly-fed plant: rotor voltage limit 0.4 pu, rotor current reference limit 1.5 pu, anti-windup, a DC chopper from 1.10 to 1.15 pu; trips read off the run at a DC voltage outside 0.75 to 1.25 pu, rotor current above 2 pu, terminal voltage outside 0.8 to 1.2 pu for 0.1 s, speed outside 0.65 to 1.35 pu. No crowbar, and the plant is not disconnected Which trip comes first and when (step 33) Rotor current trip at 1.5, 2 and 3 pu and left out. Round figures, not a manufacturer's That an unstable case trips and a stable one does not holds at every level tried. Which trip is first, and how well the modes give its time, depend on the levels
A31 The DC side of the converter is a constant power source or sink The negative conductance of a load and the DC-voltage-loop modes Not tested. A real source or load behind the DC link has dynamics of its own Worst case for a load: no relief from the load itself
A32 A converter without a phase-locked loop is the three-phase average of supplies whose current follows the voltage waveform; its voltage measurement filter is ten times faster than that of a converter with a phase-locked loop The follow family of dataset C1 With the slower filter the current lags the voltage by tens of degrees and some converters are unstable on an ideal voltage; with the faster one none is (step 17) Representative, not tied to a product. Single-phase effects at twice the line frequency are left out
A33 With a phase-locked loop the reactive current reference is the constant that holds the terminal voltage at 1 pu; there is no AC voltage loop Weak-grid results; a voltage loop adds a mode and changes the admittance at low frequency Not tested Open
A34 One aggregate converter at one terminal Interaction between converters of different kinds on the same network Step 27: a source and a load on one bus, 65,536 cases. Unit-by-unit screening misses 6 % to 16 % of the unstable pairs Lifted for two converters on a common bus (step 27) and for a doubly-fed plant beside a converter, at one terminal and a transformer apart (step 32: the reference screen clears no unstable case in 32,767 pairs). Open for more than two units and for a collector network
A35 Scans are taken from the linearised model on a logarithmic grid of 4,001 points from −2,000 to 2,000 Hz; a coarse scan is that grid thinned, and scan error is independent complex noise on each entry How fine a real scan must be, and what noise does (step 18) Thinned to 1,001, 251, 101 and 51 points; noise of 5 % and 20 %. A linear grid and systematic error not tested Spacing figures hold as a percentage of frequency
A36 In the noise study the network impedance is exact and the noise level of the scan is known to the fit Margins quoted against scan error in step 20 Network error studied in step 22 with the plant exact: 0.08 1/s per percent in the sub-synchronous band. Scan noise and network error together not tested Partly closed. The noise level still has to be estimated in practice